Saturday, July 31, 2010
Ashburn, VA
64 ºF Low
Last update: 7/31/10 4:20 AM EDT

LCPS Purchases $160,000 Hybrid School Bus

Rate this:
Friday, 29 January 2010
 
 

You, the taxpayer, are the owner of a new $160,000 hybrid yellow school bus, the first “green” school bus in Virginia and one of only 12 in the country. 

LCPS purchased the hybrid school bus, LCPS Bus #777, which arrived earlier in January and will be used to transport Loudoun students to Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology. The only mark on the bus that distinguishes it as being green is the logo C2 e Hybrid  on the rear of the vehicle. Otherwise, it looks like any other new yellow school bus and has a similar conventional capacity of 77 elementary students or 44 adults.

The Thomas Built bus cost about $60,000 more than the traditional yellow school bus, uses about 30 percent less fuel and gets 11 miles to the gallon as opposed to eight miles for a conventional school bus. LCPS purchased the bus from Sonny Merryman Inc. of Lynchburg, Virginia.

The bus runs on hybrid technology, using an electric motor which runs the bus up to a speed of 25 mph, at which point the standard diesel engine takes over. The technology is similar to that of the Ford Escape hybrid. When the driver eases off the accelerator, the hybrid’s electric cell generates it own electricity, so energy is not lost out the tailpipe, but instead harnessed by an electric motor which charges the battery, according to the LCPS announcement. Also, should the electric motor fail, the bus would then revert to the diesel engine, assuring the bus and passengers are not stranded because of an electrical malfunction.

“There is no competitive alternative in the hybrid field to the Thomas,” said LCPS Fleet Services Manager Josh Lunsford of the system’s new bus.

Al Hampton, director of LCPS transportation, explained the bus “has all the same safety features as any other school bus, which is the safest mode of land transportation that there is.” Hampton said LCPS will conduct a field test of the bus to gauge mileage and make other assessments to determine whether purchases of additional hybrid buses is warranted.

 

 


Terms for viewing user comments: Loudoun Independent does not endorse or control the content of posts submitted by others to various pages of Loudoun Independent websites. By using and/or submitting content to Loudoun Independent sites, you accept all responsibilities, agree to release Loudoun Independent, its parents and affiliates from any and all liability and obligations whatsoever in connection with or arising from your use of the sites, and further agree to the Terms of Use.

Comments

Bane (not verified)

Who approved this boondoggle? Can someone compute how long it takes to pay off the extra $60,000 cost by getting an extra 3 miles to the gallon? Whoever approved this purchase should be fired for wasting taxpayer money.

CPA (not verified)

For every 100,000 miles driven it would save $10,200 with fuel at $3 per gallon. Therefore, it would take about 600,000 miles just to break even. However, by that time you probably have to replace the expensive battery pack. What a lousy deal for the taxpayers! No wonder there are only 12 of these in the country. Most other school districts have the common sense not to buy one. Did LCPS consider buses that run on natural gas if they were so eager to "Go Green"?

Public_Watchdog (not verified)

Thank you Bane and CPA for understanding the fallacy behind hybrid buses.

THEY ARE NOT WORTH THE EXTRA COST!!! If you can not recoup the "upcharge" through fuel economies, then it is flatly a waste of money. A new 2010 diesel bus would have near the same emissions levels without the extra $60,000 price tag. Foolish spending!!!

Anonymous (not verified)

None of the hybrids make sense. At an autoshow, my wife noticed a Prius cost $24k and $500/year in fuel while a Corolla was $18k and $1k/year fuel. Same caluculation to make up $6k difference at $500/yr takes 12 years. Go figure...

Anonymous (not verified)

A criticial part of any financial analysis that is often ignored is the time value of money. There may be finance charges on that $60k differential, or if it was paid for with cash you have to figure the money could have been invested and yielding a return. If the $60k really costs $90k to finance, then it is even more of a waste of taxpayer money.

Ed Myers (not verified)

When diesel goes to $4.50 a gallon (remember that?) the fuel savings is $15K per 100,000 miles. And when the price of the hybrid bus drops to $30K difference as the cost of batteries declines over the next year the technology might become green as in saving money. You have to have real world experience with the technology to accurately decided at what point (if ever) it makes sense to buy hybrids in order to save money.

A pilot project evaluating alternative fuels makes sense to minimize the risk to the county budget of a sudden spike in energy prices. Those claiming this is a boondoggle are engaged in knee-jerk hyperbole. Wait to complain when they propose buying more than one without evaluating the cost.

dingus5 (not verified)

Thanks to the posters for proving that a hybrid vehicle's only advantage is to boos the egos of the trendy green environmentalists who drive them.

dingus5 (not verified)

"boost", not "boos", sorry.

Are we in San Francisco? (not verified)

I just moved here so maybe somebody can fill me in.

Best I can determine Loudoun County is mostly conservative in its voting tendencies (with the exception of Middleberg and Sterling), so why does it seem like every position of power (board of supervisors, school board, etc) is held by some far-left wack job?

High taxes, out of control spending, faux-environmentalism, protection for cross dressers...what the heck is going on around here?

Anonymous (not verified)

That may have been the case formerly, but the influx of liberals (fleeing the suburban sprawl that they helped create in Fairfax County, Arlington, Falls Church, etc.) has shifted the voting dynamics to the left. Fiscal responsibility and limited government are a thing of the past...

Anonymous (not verified)

When there are complaints about not being able to meet their budget this year, they should be limiting extravagent expenses such as this. Let someone else experiment with their taxpayer's money. When the costs is equal to (or even close to) a regular bus, fine, then they can buy them.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Loading...
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated.